Known Ring Codes
Heir
‡|||| |||||
Danger
††||| |||||
Protector
|‡||| |||||
Hostile
|†||| |||†|
In Direct Service
||††| |||||
Gate
||†|| ||†||
Death
||||‡ |||||
Ritual
||||† †||||
Initiate
||||† ||†||
Birth
||||| ‡||||
Sacred Site
||||| ||‡||
Rebirth
||||| ||||‡


 
Strange in Upstate - Puzzle Rant
So as it turns out, both the Seraphim and the SACRED SITE were clues as to how to fully solve the puzzle. A Seraph is an angel on fire. Combine that with a web site and you are directed to look for Strange in Upstate on the free website host angelfire.com: http://strangeinupstate.angelfire.com/

This is why I am usually never any good at puzzles in ARGs because I just can't grasp the randomness of the elements that puzzle creators put in because they think that it's a good idea. Yes, it was possible for us to originally solve note3 just based on elements in the puzzle - but when most people think of trying to discover a new website, looking for an Angelfire site is not on the top of their list. If you're creating a new website and you aren't pointing to either a standard .com or another website on the same service as yours (like a tumblr site pointing to another tumblr site), then any pointers to that website should be specific and unambiguous. You shouldn't have to guess.

I think I'm even more pissed off at the second puzzle (note4) because it was completely random there what elements you took. You ignored IMITATE but used ||||† ||†. Used SACRED SITE but ignored ||||| ||‡||. If I find out that the handwritten words and lines end up meaning nothing overall, I am going to kill a puppy by throwing it through the PM's kitchen window.

 
Strange in Upstate
Okay, enough ranting about puzzles. Let's look at the Strange in Upstate website. It's almost your standard conspiracy website, except for the fact that it doesn't have multi-colored text on a black background with lots of animated images as proof about the claims that they make. §

Most of the entries are "legitimate" in the conspiracy world. I had heard about Champ and the 13 Curves before and Googling gives you some information on Happy Valley, the Mormons, the Seventh Day Adventists and Whitley Strieber. By the way, don't go Googling around for Whitley Streiber. Next thing you know you're on a website listening to a podcast about how Stanley Kubrik faked the moon landing video footage and told about it in his later films and then by the time you get to the part where you are informed that the moon is an artificial construct for a race of aliens observing the Earth, you've lost half your braincells.

Anyway, one of the entries doesn't have any additional information to find on Google: The Sons of Grace. It seems that the Sons of Grace are an actual institution in the area. Publicly they seem to be a charitable organization but most believe that the charity part is just a front its deeper meaning, although no one knows what that is. The article doesn't talk about how one becomes a member (do you have to be a male relative of the original Edmund Grace?) but it does talk about how members often wear two hematite rings. The meaning of the rings are unknown, but it's suggested that it could be a secret code depending on what fingers the rings are worn on.
 
Ring Code Theory
A couple of people on the Unfiction forums emailed Strange in Upstate to ask him more about the rings and what the code meant. Strange in Upstate responded "like you wear the rings one way it means ur like the new guy, and if you wear them another it means ur gonna take a bitch out, or that ur working for some dark god or something".

If that's the case, we can make some educated guesses based on the words that Mystery Man has given to go along with the ring positions. Of course, there is also a question as to how the lines translate directly to the fingers. Is it palms down (Pinky -> Thumb - Thumb -> Pinky), palms up (Thumb -> Pinky - Pinky -> Thumb) or a combination of both? I'd vote the first way, but I've been wrong about things in this ARG a lot so far.
Initiate: ||||† ||†||

Heir: ‡|||| |||||

Angry/Ready to Fight/Enemy [Hostile]: |†||| |||†|

Servant [In Direct Service]: ||††| |||||

Religious Figure [Sacred Site]: ||||| ||‡||
Right now these are all just guesses, but hopefully we'll get more concrete information later that lets us refine our 'definitions' of the ring patterns.
 
Car Trouble
Poor Tom is not having a very good day. His car won't start. And when you live in the middle of nowhere, your car is very important to you. I can sympathize. My poor car is slowly dying and it sucks when it has to go into the shop. Hopefully Tom's problems will be a lot cheaper to fix than mine were and he can get back on the road soon. §
 
Another Bad Day
Poor Tom. His car is still broken - expensive electrical issues. Plus he has a monster headache. And to top it all off - it's snowing out. I'm amazed he was able to write up such a long blog post. If it was me, I would have just stayed in bed all day with a cold compress for my head and a huge pile of blankets to keep the rest of me toasty. But because of all the issues, he hasn't been able to mail anything out to anyone. So if you're wondering where your business card from him is, it's still at the Windmill. §
 
Silver Key Note
The Mystery Man is back to leaving notes. He must be satisfied that we found the Strange in Upstate website because no pictures of Seraphim this time. Instead, we get a snippet of the H.P. Lovecraft story "Through The Gates of the Silver Key". §

So surprise, surprise - the puzzle isn't the same form as any of the other puzzles we've encountered. It has the missing letters of the two newspaper articles, but none of the previous methods used have proven worthwhile.
 he   w    Car  r   n s  t n s b    g ng  o e e y k o   a d s spe  ed
There were Carters in settings belonging to every known and suspected

  e of
age of Earth's history, and to remoter ages of earthly entity transcending

knowledge, suspicion, and credibility; Carters of forms both

non-human, vertebrate and invertebrate, conscious and 

vegetable. And more, there were Carters having n

earthly life, but moving outrageously amid

and systems and galaxies and cosmic co

drifting from world to world, univer
||||| ‡||||
Birth
The missing letters are: TREERETESIETIGELONITVRNWNNUCTAG. They aren't usable as is (like the first note). It's not a Vigenère with a keyword of BIRTH (via the obit note). It's not taking every 6th letter (ala the Seraphim). It's not a ROT. Simple substitution doesn't seem likely. A few too many letters to get a easily identifiable anagram out of it. And so basically we're stuck until Mystery Man gives us another clue because he is such a terrible puzzle creator.
 
Easter Break
It's been a few days since we've heard from Thomas. Normally no news would be good news, but not in Windmill land. On the 21st, Thomas "woke up" to find himself in a small, pitch black, stone chamber where he was being watched by something that he couldn't see. He was kept in that cell until the sun rose, where he then noticed he was back in his room. Personally to me it sounds like he just experienced a night terror (with maybe a bit of sleep paralysis thrown in), but what do I know? I certainly can't blame him for wanting to get away from the Windmill for a while and deciding to spend the Easter weekend at his dad's. §
 
The Silver Key Solve
Since it had been 4 days without anyone coming up for a solution to the Silver Key note, Thomas gave us some of his thoughts on the puzzle.
All the other notes have hidden some kind of code, so, this one probably does too, but I can’t for the life of me figure out what it is. Why double the first line like that? Why are half the letters missing? Even sitting there in plain black and white, the meaning eludes me. God it makes me feel stupid.
I wish I could say that the hint made everything all clear and that I should have felt stupid for not seeing the solution earlier, but it didn't. It did lead me to look at both the given and missing letters as being important to the puzzle, rather than just the missing letters.
 he   w    Car  r   n s  t n s b    g ng  o e e y k o   a d s spe  ed   e of		given
T  re  ere    te s i   et i g   elon i   t   v r   n wn  n   u   ct   ag		missing
Apparently the Mystery Man was inspired by Thomas' painting of the Windmill floor, because he decided to use Binary in this puzzle (instead of reusing any of his previous methods). Setting the missing letters = 0 and the given letters = 1 then reading in the original order, you get 0110010001110010011001010110000101101101011010010110111001100111 which decodes to dreaming. Slap a .html on the end of that and you get taken to dreaming.html.
 
Dreaming
The new Dreaming page appears to be a copy of some deleted text from Tom's blog. The first and last paragraphs are taken from his entry on 4/13, but the middle part is all new. The redacted text is Thomas wondering if he is becoming schizophrenic and if he could have broken the window and killed a bird without realizing it. §

The bit about the camera not working at the Windmill though is a bit creepy. It would be interesting to see if this was just a problem Tom experiences or if someone else came out to the Windmill, would they be able to get the camera working. If there is some sort of weird electrical interference going on, it might explain why his car isn't working.

It also might explain why Thomas is getting such intense headaches. Once upon a time, I used to know some people who were acutely bothered by electrical fields, so much so that some of them would retreat to the mountains of West Virginia during the summer just to get away from the problems. Makes me wonder if Tom ever dreamed of being a cat.

Oddly though, the image on the page is not a screenshot of Tom's computer while he was writing the blog. It seems to be a photocopy of a print out of what Tom originally wrote. Not only that, it appears that whatever photocopier was used was also used for the first newspaper article and the second seraph note. All three have a similar 'notch' on the lower left-hand edge of the image. So 'whoever' is leaving the notes for Tom is also able to upload images to his website.

I'm guessing that the name of the file (20110420165135.jpg) is just the time stamp it was created. 2011 is obviously the year with 04 being the month. The Silver Key note appeared on the 20th. I'm guessing it was placed around 4:51 pm (16:51:35). If Tom was home all that time, that would mean that if it was an outsider, they must have remote access to his server in order to be able to upload stuff. He should really check to see if he has a keylogger (or else figure out a way to stop himself from uploading stuff without realizing it).
 
A Stalker?
While still at his dad's, Tom tweeted that he got another note placed under his windshield wiper. This one said 'Don't StaY HerE' written on the same type of paper as the original Welcome note. So either Tom has a stalker who is willing to follow him all the way out to his father's house, or Tom is rapidly developing a dissociative disorder.
 
Enaxor's Painting
Enaxor received the original Roosting Bridge painting from Tom in the mail. Not only that, but the original 'Welcome to the area neighbor' note was in the package as well as another diary page from Tom. §

Hmm, so the Roosting Bridge painting went missing like everything else. Does this mean that Tom didn't actually send the package? Sure there is a note from him in there, but he could have printed that up beforehand and it could have been taken along with the rest of the stuff. Of course, that's assuming that there really is a Mystery Man and it is not Tom's subconscious doing all of this. I seriously doubt that Tom would have sent the diary page knowingly. But if it is Tom's subconscious, then that means that his alter-ego knows about the ring code somehow.
 
Back to the Windmill
Tom is back at the Windmill. He decided that he didn't really want to find out if the 'Don't stay here' note was a threat or not and so, wanting to protect his family, decided to err on the side of caution. Luckily for us, him being back at the Windmill means we get a very long update from him now that he has his computer back. §

The highlights:
  • He links to the dreaming page. He confirms it is part of a private journal that he was keeping and that he did not put it up on the website.
  • He confirms that the diary page Enaxor received was part of the same journal. He admits to mailing the painting and the thank you letter, but not the Welcome note or the diary page.
  • He's no longer going to keep a private journal since it's no longer private. He'll share it all with us instead.
  • The reason he didn't confide in his therapist during his last session is because he noticed that she was wearing a black hematite ring on her finger. He doesn't say what finger it was on, but thinks that she was wearing two rings on one finger.
  • Tom wasn't born chromosomally male. That's why he visits his therapist every month and takes injections of testosterone. He'll answer well-intentioned questions via email, but doesn't want it to take over his blog.
  • Art prints are now available for $12 USD plus shipping. If you want one, email him with 'PRINT' in the subject.
  • He finally has a PO Box so business cards should be out soon. You are also free to mail him since he likes receiving snail mail. He'll only be able to check the mail once a week, so be patient if you mail him anything.
  • His snail mail address is: Thomas Pickman
    P.O. Box 93045
    Rochester, NY 14692
  • He's changing his sleep schedule so that he's now sleeping during the day and will be awake at night. So look for update times accordingly.
I'm really most curious as to what rings his therapist has. The only double ring entries we have so far are Protector, Heir and Sacred Site. If his Doctor is a Protector, it may mean that Thomas doesn't have anything to fear from her. Unless of course a Protector only protects members/secrets of the cult. Then he could have a lot to worry about. We really need to find out more about the various members of the cult.
 
Just Life
Nothing exciting has been happening to Thomas lately, so I guess that's a good thing. No notes, no nightmares. He did see Jessica while he was out shopping, but since she didn't see (or acknowledge) him, there was no drama. The only real information he gives us is that he thinks that the Doctor's rings were on her left ring finger. So it would probably seem that she is a Protector |‡||| ||||| . If only we know what she is supposed to Protect. §
 
Sickness
It's been several days since we've heard from Thomas. It turns out he's been extremely sick (and not killed by some whacked out member of the Sons of Grace). He's had a few more of the stone chamber nightmare, but was too sick to panic. §

The Mystery Man wasn't deathly ill as he managed to leave another note for Tom. At least his puzzle is straight forward this time. Just take the underlined letters and it spells BERGMAN DIARY. Is that where this note comes from? Peter Bergman's diary? It sounds like it could be, but why give us just a page and not the whole thing - especially if it sheds light on the Sons of Grace? Or maybe Mystery Man only has a part of the diary and wants us to look for the rest of it. But where would we even begin to look? §
 
All Quiet on the Windmill Front
It's been rather quiet in Windmill-land the last week or so. Thomas has posted a couple of updates, but nothing too exciting, which is why partially why the guide hasn't been updated in the meantime. That and I'm lazy. But with Thomas mailing stuff out earlier this week, we're in for a new round of note leaving goodness. So let's get caught up.
 
Fight With Dad
When we last left Tom, he had been really sick. He seems to have gotten better, but the whole situation with the Windmill got him wanting out. He asked his dad if he could move back home, but his dad refused. Maybe his dad noticed Tom acting strange around his house and wanted him out in case he snapped? §

Thomas is afraid that the Sons of Grace might Cthulu worshipers since the note from Bergman's diary possibly references the Necronomicon. Great. Just what I needed. To throw myself up against another cult that worships an Elder God. I wonder who would end up being worse: Cthulu or Yog-Sothoth.
 
Mr. Notes
Thomas hasn't received any new notes from the mystery man (who he has taken to calling Mr. Notes now) but he has seen him (or at least someone) prowling around the woods at night. And it seems that Mr. Notes has a friend that sometimes accompanies him. I wonder what he's doing wandering through the woods at night. And why hasn't he left Thomas any messages lately? Are we missing something or is he just pissed that I got annoyed at his puzzles? §
 
Rain, Rain, Go Away
It's been raining a lot in upstate NY (and the rest of the North East) this past month. There's been some flooding in areas and in general it's just been a very grey month. It sucks. Can't wait for summer. The sun is supposed to shine then, correct?

Still no new correspondence from Mr. Notes. Thomas keeps seeing him and his light in the woods though. Thomas said that it seems like Mr. Notes and pal are acting like some sort of guard. Are they guarding Tom from the Sons of Grace? Are they guarding the Sons of Grace from Tom? Or are they guarding something completely else? The hiding place of the Bergman diary, perhaps? §
 
A Package from Tom
Yesterday, I received a package from Tom. It contained a Roosting Bridge print that I bought from him, a new drawing Thomas made of Mr. Notes, a letter in reply to a postcard I sent him, and an extra note from Mr. Notes himself! §

It seems that Mr. Notes has traded in his codebook for a pair of scissors, because instead of a cipher, he's just chopped up what appears to be another page from Bergman's diary and photocopied the pieces. But when you put it all back together, you can see that he has left one of his patented underlined messages: HEED MY NOTES §

I really wish we could send a message back to Mr. Notes saying that we are heeding his notes. We just don't know what the hell he's driving at. However the latest diary page scares the crap out of me. Although Bergman says the 'Dweller of the Threshold', I wonder if he really didn't mean 'Lurker at the Threshold' which would mean that the Sons of Grace are interested in Yog-Sothoth. Which means they are batshit crazy. And dangerous. But it's still rather confusing if Mr. Notes wants us to stay away from the Sons of Grace why he is drawing so much attention to them. It's not like Thomas (or any of us for that matter) was investigating the Sons before the notes were left. Sure he was seeing his therapist, but that's just a coincidence. Right?
 
Other People's Packages
Several other people received packages from Tom. They all seemed to have gotten a handwritten letter from Tom, a sketch by Tom and a message from Mr. Notes. The messages from Mr. Notes are the same chopped up message as above, but the ring codes are different.

||||‡ |||||
Death

||||| ||||‡
ReBIRtH

 
Tom Talks Madness
Tom is not happy about the packages that we've received. He doesn't understand how the extra notes got into the packages. He's been dreaming a lot, even in the daytime. He also seems to be spiraling down into depression since he lays in bed all day and just stares at the ceiling. He's not even painting anymore. Hopefully he'll snap out of it soon. §
 
Continue to Page 3 >>



See the Intro page for a list of all the websites, plus brief information about this guide and the game.