Known Ring Codes
Heir
‡|||| |||||
Danger
††||| |||||
Protector
|‡||| |||||
Hostile
|†||| |||†|
In Direct Service
||††| |||||
Gate
||†|| ||†||
Death
||||‡ |||||
Ritual
||||† †||||
Initiate
||||† ||†||
Birth
||||| ‡||||
Sacred Site
||||| ||‡||
Rebirth
||||| ||||‡


 
Why This Guide Is So Late
I've been vaguely following The Abandonded Windmill ever since I first found out about it, but for some reason haven't been able to completely commit to it. Sadly, I think it is because I have become so jaded and disappointed in the ARG scene that I haven't been able to fall in love with this game for fear of getting burned yet again. Certainly the ARG itself hasn't raised any red flags that would cause me to not want to play. And so I'm hoping that forcing myself to write this guide will get me back into the swing of things because I really do want to fall in love with this game. I just hope it doesn't end before I get the first draft of the guide up. That would suck.
 
@TPickman
So this game first came to our attention when a Thomas Pickman (@TPickman) started following a bunch of ARGers on Twitter. His tweets stated that he is a painter and that he started a new website at theabandonedwindmill.com.
 
The Abandoned Windmill
The Abandoned Windmill was a lot more fleshed out than his twitter page. Sadly, it appears that Thomas went to the Mystery Meat Navigation school, so it's impossible to tell at a glance just what the different sections of his website are. Luckily he at least names his pages with descriptive titles, so tabbing through will let you check out the page names. Before getting into the blog, let's take a look at a couple of other things first. The quote "Et in Arcadia ego." translates to "I, Death, am even in Paradise." Thomas explains in a later email that to him it means "Everything we see and touch has death, an end, lurking somewhere below the surface." So great - there is going to be death lurking underneath the windmill, isn't there?

One other thing to look at is the odd 404 page. For some reason it contains an animated .gif with 25 frames of random static. That wouldn't necessarily be unusual except that frame 18 has the word 'below' written in it. There isn't a /below directory or a below.html, so I have no idea what it's in references to at this point.
 
Pickman's Blog
Pickman's blog has more entries than his Twitter account, but that's to be expected since he started it a few days prior to getting an internet connection in his new home at the windmill. He recently broke up with his girlfriend of three years and moved into an old windmill in the country that his father owns for some reason.

So far things seem fairly normal for life in the country. It's too quiet (except of course when the wind blows and things start making odd creaking noises), ground is muddy from the start of the spring thaw and a bird flew through his window. It must have been a very thin window/a huge crow because I have at least one bird a month ram into my breakfast nook windows and all it leaves is just a mess of feathers on the outside. I can however sympathize with things being too quiet. Never bothered me growing up, but after living 10 years in Southern California, I now require some sort of white noise happening in order to get to sleep. §

There was one odd thing in the blog entries and that is all the misspellings on the 3/23/11 entry. Are they just mistakes made because he was too tired to type or is there an actual message in the misspellings? Based on the fact that several misspellings were corrected after being pointed out on the Unfiction forums but these still remain suggest that they are important. However, no one has been able to come up with anything concrete about the meaning of the misspellings.

But now I need my monde off the horror. Because I haven’t slept in two days, and my dad needs me to be able to function tomorrow. Can't stop uawning as it is. We’re moving my stuff into the studio he’s letting me use. It’s a ways out of the city, but at least thatt way hi and I won’t be crowding each othwr; and especially not my step mom.

It’s getting harder to type, so, I’m going to sine off and get some shut-eye.

 
Painting in the Woods
Thomas ventured outside and stayed out all day painting. It must have been much warmer where he was or he was all bundled up because it was only in the low 30s where I was. While he was outside he says that he saw someone moving through the woods even though no one is supposed to be around there. It's probably too logical/mundane to assume that he saw a deer or even a bear at a distance.

It should also be mentioned that with this update Thomas added a direct link to the latest blog on the front page. So now you can just click on the starburst pattern below the painting instead of remembering what section of the painting to click and then clicking through all the previous entries. §
 
A Mysterious Note
Well, maybe there really was someone walking around in the woods because when Thomas woke up and went outside, there was a note taped to his door. And by note I mean a terrible photocopy of a newspaper article. Luckily for us, Thomas found it on his way out so he was able to take it and the previous note to the library and scan then in so that we can see them. Thomas left his own note for the mystery person saying "Stop leaving notes. Introduce yourself." I would have thrown in a "Please" or maybe a "Fuck Off" but that's just me.

While he was in town, Thomas picked up some more paint and has issued a call for suggestions for what to paint. So if you have any photographs that you own the rights to, you can send it to him in an email and it might just inspire him to create a new painting. §
 
The Newspaper Puzzle
The note that the mysterious person taped to Thomas' door has two very strange things about it. The first is that a number of letters are missing from the text (replaced behind the cut in purple). The second is that there odd handwritten remarks below the article. §

The missing letters bit is the easiest to solve. Taking the letters that are missing, you get the rather cryptic message: BEWARE THE MEN IN BLACK RINGS. Gee thanks, Mystery Man. That doesn't seem ominous at all. Are the men in black rings something Thomas would have come across if not told about them? And is Mystery Man a member of the men in black rings or does he just know about them because he is a local and doesn't want Thomas to get hurt?

Unfortunately, while the missing letters were easy to solve, the handwritten message isn't as easy. In fact, three weeks later and we still don't really know what to do with them. It's obviously important because I doubt MM would have written it if it wasn't. But apparently it's not important enough for him to write it out in plain English. We'll just have to wait and see if anything comes of it.
 
Hacked!
Strange things are afoot at the windmill. Odd tweets from Thomas ("beware the men in black rings beware the men in black beware the men in beware the men beware the beware eraweb eraweb eht eraweb nem eht er") and the main site changed and started pulsing red. (Or so I read. I actually missed this part and have no idea what it actually looked like.)

It all changed back a few hours later when Thomas woke up and realized that someone hacked his accounts. He reverted the site back to its original form and deleted the offending tweets and set up some more secure passwords so this type of thing won't happen again. §
 
April Fools' Day
Luckily the hacking didn't happen a day later because we might have thought it was just part of April Fools' Day. Instead, we get a very punny painting that references the classic Lovecraft story Pickman's Model. §
 
An Obituary
Thomas got another note from the Mystery Man - this time an obituary for a Mr. Edmund Grace (who you might remember as the person who reported the fire at Bergman Mill). If that wasn't creepy enough, now it seems that someone is stealing things from the windmill while Thomas is out. All of the previous notes have gone missing. Why would you give someone a warning note only to take it back a few days later? Is there someone else out there who doesn't want Thomas to be warned (or who thinks that warning him might put him in more danger)? §

You'll notice that there are more letters missing from this clipping: USBULELSBX. § Those are obviously not usable in their current form and anagramming doesn't help either. That's because Mystery Man is going through his "Traditional But Overused Ciphers and Codes for ARGs" handbook and decided he really needed to use a Vigenère cipher. Luckily he gave us the keyword HEIR so his message becomes: NOT DEAD BUT.

NOT DEAD BUT what? Not dead but missing? Not dead but a zombie? Not dead but currently living under your windmill and stealing things from you so you go slowly insane? Why go through the trouble of a: find the obit, b: erasing letters to fit a Vigenère, c: writing down the keyword, d: taping it to a door - only to be so overly cryptic that your warning is practically useless? It makes no freaking sense.

We also have another set of the lines, although this one is different in that there are two cross bars on the first line instead of just one. Is that to signify that the Heir is important? That this is a Vigenère? A new character? Whatever it is, we still haven't figured out a use for marks yet.
 
Things Are Disappearing
This was actually a double update, with Thomas writing a second post about a game he used to play with his sister called "Things Are Disappearing." It actually sounds kinda creepy. He doesn't really say if things are always disappearing or only sometimes. Not sure which would be more disturbing, actually. §

So are the notes going missing part of this game? Is Thomas doing this to himself or could the Mystery Man somehow know about this game? Or is Thomas maybe just a really forgetful slob who has no idea where he put things and chalks it up to things that go bump in the night?
 
Visiting His Sister
After being reminded of the Things Are Disappearing game, Thomas decided to take an impulse road trip to see his sister in Maryland. He must have really felt like he needed to talk to her in person to make a fourteen hour round trip drive to see her. It doesn't seem like she gave him any real advice on what to do about the Mystery Man, but she did give him a rather creepy painting of a doll he had done years earlier for her. §

The doll is übercreepy. For starters, it looks like it has a spike coming out of its head. I'm hoping it's just because he didn't have the correct size doll stand and that it's not meant to have a spike coming out of its head. But then again, the face is all bloody and it looks like it's crying tears, so maybe the spike is meant to be there. Poor thing looks more like a torture victim than a doll. The right arm looks like it has been wrenched backwards and the right ankle looks like it's been hit with a sledgehammer and broken. Personally, I think if my brother had painted that for me, I would have set fire to it rather than hold onto it for several years. But that's just me.
 
The Windmill Floor Puzzle
It was noticed by oski90 on Unfiction that the painting of the Windmill floor had an unusual pattern. Several of the tiles had diagonal swipes painted through them. If you set the plain tiles to 0 and the swiped tiles to 1, you can get a string of 8-bit binary (since there are 8 tiles per row shown).
01110011 = s
01100101 = e
01100001 = a
01101100 = l
So the floor tiles spell out SEAL but that's not where this puzzle ends. SEAL directs you to a new page on Thomas' site, http://www.theabandonedwindmill.com/seal.html which links to a new, and rather disturbing picture, 1678230.jpg.

What the hell? Is that supposed to be a picture of Thomas breaking the window above his sink? I somehow imagined him taller since the painting looks more like a little kid than a 22 year old guy. I know I could reach the window over my kitchen sink with a hammer without resorting to climbing in the sink and I'm not that tall. Maybe we should ask Thomas if he owns a pair of red striped boxer shorts or know anyone who does.

It's unknown if the numbers 1678230 mean anything. It's not a phone number in the 585 (or even 315) area code. It doesn't lead to a new page or directory. It doesn't translate into any readable words. So for now, it's a mystery.
 
Business Cards
Thomas tweeted that he was going to be making up some business cards, presumably to advertise himself as an artist for hire, and is willing to mail one to anyone who wants one. So if you want a business card, drop him an email (pickman@theabandonedwindmill.com) with your mailing address and he'll send one to you when he gets them printed up.
 
Mindgames
Well, either Thomas is a liar, going crazy or someone is fucking with him because he swears he didn't put either the SEAL message in his painting intentionally and has never seen the 1678230 picture at all. Not only did he never put it up on his website, it doesn't exist at all on his computer and he is not the person that drew the picture. In fact, he's rather freaked out about the whole thing and was almost ready to stop blogging altogether, except he realized that would mean whoever was doing this to him had won, and Thomas wasn't going to let that happen. So the blog and all his fury remains. §

There's two minor things of note that should be mentioned about Thomas' latest entry. First, he's still not accepting commissions, but he might be tempted if you send him the right photograph for inspiration. He will be selling those paintings with first dibs going to the original photographers. If there is interest prints might also be available sometime in the future.

Secondly, he's added a comment section on the blog entries now. The previous entries don't have it, but all of the future ones should.
 
A Strange Visitor
Thomas has had his first real visitor to the Windmill. A Mr. Emmet Grace stopped by to have a chat. It turns out Emmet's family owns most of the land around the Windmill. Emmet was wondering if Thomas had been out in the woods at night because he had seen someone prowling around. It's a good thing Thomas told him 'No' because the mysterious prowler defaced some of the Grace property and things might have gotten ugly if Thomas was suspected of it. §

Is this Emmet the son of Edmund Grace (the guy from the obit) or is he yet another Grace? If this Emmet is the son of Edmund, than he was born rather late. Thomas' says this Emmet was in his early 40s and Edmund died when he was 87 so you do the math. Regardless, the family has a very odd obsession with naming their children with names starting with E. Edmund Erasmus, Emmet, Edmund II. Do the girls get the E treatment or just the boys?
 
The Seraphim Note
It's been a few days, but the Mystery Man is back to leaving notes on Thomas' door. This time he left a picture of a seraphim with a string of typewritten letters (QWERSMOTWOPLREFAPBOSNMQGCLURELEIANTPNOOUCIHYPJSSRURDTQAAVSIOTWAE) and another set of handwritten lines (||||† ||†|| INiTIATE). §

It would be really nice to know why the hell he is doing this. It would be ever nicer if he just left his "warnings" in plain English as we a: have no idea what to do with the string of letters and b: are still clueless about the handwritten lines. There has to be a purpose them, otherwise why bother? Unless of course the Mystery Man is just batshit insane but I don't want to think about that.
 
A Brief Update
A brief update by Thomas to let us know that he's still alive and that everything is calm in Windmill land. He spent the night at his father's and asked him questions about the Grace Mission House where Emmet said he worked. Thomas didn't get much information from his dad, other than the fact that the Grace's tend to keep to themselves. Thomas also promises scans of two of his latest paintings in the next day or so. He's also still accepting photos and addresses if anyone wants to send him anything. §
 
New Paintings
Thomas has finished his first two reader inspired paintings: March of the Red Rook and Roosting Bridge. So now he finally has something up on his Portfolio page. He also started wondering if maybe he could have broken his kitchen window from the inside and went to see if there was any glass outside - and there were a few shards outside. Uh ohes. But then again, there was supposedly glass in the sink when he found the dead bird. So if he did break the window from the inside, he must have gone outside, gathered up the pieces of glass, found a dead bird and brought them all back upstairs and deposited them in his kitchen sink. Possible, but it seems unlikely. It would make more sense that he broke the window in a fugue and then just imagined the dead bird when he 'awoke'. Still strange either way. §
 
The Seraphim Solve
The biggest thing to come out of the new paintings entry is a hint to the Seraphim note puzzle. Thomas said "my advice is just throw the stupid letters out" and that inspired RandomGuy26 to the solution. He had noticed the first 4 letters of the string were QWER like on a keyboard. After throwing those out, he started taking every 5th letter (like the first set of handwritten lines). When that didn't work, he took the 5th then 3rd set of letters and came up with the solution: STRANGE IN UPSTATE §

So things are strange in upstate? You don't say. I could have told that you without the puzzle. I mean, things would have to be strange if someone thought that this was a good idea. Hint: it wasn't.

Happily though we now have a use for the handwritten lines. Sadly, the same principle doesn't work on the other articles from what I can tell. So it could be that these lines were just pulling double duty as both a [poor/flawed] hint and as its overall unknown meaning.

Although the lines did eventually give us the solution, I'm not happy with the puzzle because it requires you to randomly drop elements - namely the last two | marks. If the † marks are to indicate which letters to take, then the puzzle should have required you to a: break it into 5 letter groups then b: take the 5th letter of the odd groups and 3rd letter of the even groups. Otherwise you're going to have a guessing game on your hands. I mean, if it had been |†||| ||†|| would we have taken 2 then 3 letters or could it have been 2 then 6 letters. And if the second set had just been ||||| would we have ignored it all together and just taken every X letter? A good puzzle should have a reason for every element in it. If an element is extraneous, then there is no need for it in the puzzle.
 
Seraphim Redux
So apparently we didn't solve the puzzle to Mystery Man's satisfaction because he gave Thomas another copy of it, along with a new set of handwritten lines (SACrED SITE ||||| ||‡||). §

So let's see. If we employ logic here, than it would be probable that the Sacred Site message is meant to be an additional hint to the string of letters. Since the lines are ||||| ||‡|| we could believe that it's leading us to look at every 8th letter of the string.
QWERSMOT  T
WOPLREFA  A
PBOSNMQG  G
CLURELEI  I
ANTPNOOU  U
CIHYPJSS  S
RURDTQAA  A
VSIOTWAE  E
That gives us TAGIUSAE which is meaningless. But wait! Remember that with the Obituary puzzle, the string of letters was a Vigenère with the keyword being the handwritten word. So if we decrypt TAGIUSAE with SACRED SITE we get BAERQPIW. Which is crap. Which is what Mystery Man's puzzle skills are since there is no fucking rhyme or reason to the half of the stuff he's given us so far. If he keeps this up, he's not going to have to worry about Emmet Grace or Thomas finding out who he is because I'll go up to the Windmill myself and wait around and then punch him in the nose for writing such shitty puzzles. Seriously, if you're going to have a series of related puzzles, they had better employ the same fucking logic. Otherwise you're just screwing around with your players for no reason whatsoever. This is why I hate puzzles in ARGs because people seem to think that random variety is good when in fact it's just bullshit.
 
Continue to Page 2 >>



See the Intro page for a list of all the websites, plus brief information about this guide and the game.